AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
Moderator: Site Moderators
Forum rules
Please read the forum rules before posting.
Please read the forum rules before posting.
-
- Posts: 2522
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 4:12 am
- Location: Greenwood MS USA
AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
One interesting feature of the new Radeon VII is that it features very high double precision speed.
Inherently, double precision (FP64) is one half the speed of single precision, (FP32) But in an effort to sell upmarket Workstation cards and Server cards, vendors hobble double precision in consumer cards. It does not usually impact gaming.
I have seen cards with a 32 to 1 ratio of single precision operations to double. The new Radeon VII has a very generous 4 to 1 ratio, better than most consumer gear.
Radeon VII double precision 3.5 TFLOPS, single precision 13.8 TFLOPS
Titan RTX double precision 0.389 TFLOPS, single precision 12.4 TFLOPS
So these cards are about 10% different in common math, but in scientific work the VII is impressive. It will be 9 times faster.
F@H mostly uses single precision when it can, only breaking out the slower double precision when needed to get accurate results. The VII may show us what that ratio is, because it is only a minor speed up on single precision.
(It appears that the 4 to 1 ratio is enforced in the BIOS, expect hacked BIOSes that then disappoint gamers, because their games don't use much double precision)
Inherently, double precision (FP64) is one half the speed of single precision, (FP32) But in an effort to sell upmarket Workstation cards and Server cards, vendors hobble double precision in consumer cards. It does not usually impact gaming.
I have seen cards with a 32 to 1 ratio of single precision operations to double. The new Radeon VII has a very generous 4 to 1 ratio, better than most consumer gear.
Radeon VII double precision 3.5 TFLOPS, single precision 13.8 TFLOPS
Titan RTX double precision 0.389 TFLOPS, single precision 12.4 TFLOPS
So these cards are about 10% different in common math, but in scientific work the VII is impressive. It will be 9 times faster.
F@H mostly uses single precision when it can, only breaking out the slower double precision when needed to get accurate results. The VII may show us what that ratio is, because it is only a minor speed up on single precision.
(It appears that the 4 to 1 ratio is enforced in the BIOS, expect hacked BIOSes that then disappoint gamers, because their games don't use much double precision)
Tsar of all the Rushers
I tried to remain childlike, all I achieved was childish.
A friend to those who want no friends
I tried to remain childlike, all I achieved was childish.
A friend to those who want no friends
-
- Site Moderator
- Posts: 6349
- Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2007 10:38 am
- Location: Bordeaux, France
- Contact:
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
The Radeon VII is just a rebranded Radeon Instinct MI50 which are server class GPU intended for HPC ... it seems that DP throughput has been reduced in a half but it's still quite impressive DP power.
-
- Posts: 511
- Joined: Mon May 21, 2018 4:12 pm
- Hardware configuration: Ubuntu 22.04.2 LTS; NVidia 525.60.11; 2 x 4070ti; 4070; 4060ti; 3x 3080; 3070ti; 3070
- Location: Great White North
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
AnandTech has posted FAHBench SP and DP results.
I was thinking the same thing WRT The mix of Precision. I suspect that the VII will post some interesting results which may shed some light on how much DP is used. It will be interesting to see if it varies by Project or even within Projects.
I was thinking the same thing WRT The mix of Precision. I suspect that the VII will post some interesting results which may shed some light on how much DP is used. It will be interesting to see if it varies by Project or even within Projects.
-
- Posts: 2040
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
- Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
Looks like it would do 1000k PPD except double precision boosts it more
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
So far, the FAHCores use mixed precision which is as JimbpPalmer described above, so gamers and FAH adherents won't be getting a majore increase in speed. FAHBench DP does not represent the production FAHCores but a pure DP core makes the professional GPUs look good.
Posting FAH's log:
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
The first WU I've run on the VII at complete stock (except fan speed tweaks).
Project 14152
Number of Frames Observed: 39
Min. Time / Frame : 00:00:59 - 1,688,170 PPD
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:00 - 1,646,140 PPD
Compared to some of my other cards (unfortunately my big cards haven't run this unit yet), this unit seems to be a typical PPD unit. So I'm quite impressed so far. Card power consumption is around 200W delta from idle. Not bad, but I'm hoping undervolting will improve.
Project 14152
Number of Frames Observed: 39
Min. Time / Frame : 00:00:59 - 1,688,170 PPD
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:00 - 1,646,140 PPD
Compared to some of my other cards (unfortunately my big cards haven't run this unit yet), this unit seems to be a typical PPD unit. So I'm quite impressed so far. Card power consumption is around 200W delta from idle. Not bad, but I'm hoping undervolting will improve.
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
Another: 13815
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:31 - 1,407,062 PPD
That seems in line with my Titan Xp
The general trend I'm seeing is good on the large atom count projects. On the smaller projects it drops substantially due to underutilization (power consumption drops by half as well).
14158 (A tiny atom count project)
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:16 - 419,895 PPD
Which is well below my Titan Xp at ~700k PPD (which is also well below its average).
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:31 - 1,407,062 PPD
That seems in line with my Titan Xp
The general trend I'm seeing is good on the large atom count projects. On the smaller projects it drops substantially due to underutilization (power consumption drops by half as well).
14158 (A tiny atom count project)
Avg. Time / Frame : 00:01:16 - 419,895 PPD
Which is well below my Titan Xp at ~700k PPD (which is also well below its average).
-
- Posts: 2040
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
- Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
So the Radeon VII matches a gtx 2070 or gtx 2080? Maybe the tiny atom count projects can be excluded from the Radeon VII and assigned to slower GPUs?
-
- Site Moderator
- Posts: 6349
- Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2007 10:38 am
- Location: Bordeaux, France
- Contact:
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
That's interesting ... it's been a while since we last saw numbers from high end AMD GPUs ...
I think I remember similar behaviour in the days I was using a R9 290X : it liked more the bigger projects.
I think I remember similar behaviour in the days I was using a R9 290X : it liked more the bigger projects.
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
In the early days of FAH, those involved in benchmarking found that ATI GPUs (all of them) liked bigger projects and it was tough to benchmark projects in a way that would keep those donors happy. All shaders ran identical code, even when the code contained branches, and the results of the unnecessary ops were simply ignored. I don't know if AMD still uses that same logic.
Posting FAH's log:
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
Yeah, I agree there is no way to fix it with benchmarking. The card power consumption drops by half on the smaller units. It isn't being fullyt utilized so it effectively is a "smaller" GPU at that point and should be getting lower PPD. I just haven't seen one to this level before in a GPU project (yes in CPU).
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
11719
1.13 million PPD (01:23 TPF)
1.13 million PPD (01:23 TPF)
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
See my comment here about trying to process a small number of atoms with a lot of shaders.
Posting FAH's log:
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
AMD does have ridiculous amounts of graphics memory.
Not sure if future FAH cores will make use of it or not...
@EXT: I regularly see only 87Watts used on my GTX 1060, while other cards run at 100-110W. So it's not limited to AMD.
Not sure if future FAH cores will make use of it or not...
@EXT: I regularly see only 87Watts used on my GTX 1060, while other cards run at 100-110W. So it's not limited to AMD.
-
- Site Moderator
- Posts: 6349
- Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2007 10:38 am
- Location: Bordeaux, France
- Contact:
Re: AMD Radeon VII - Double Precision
FAH doesn't use a lot of GPU memory ... maybe up to a couple of hundred MB ...