Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
Moderators: Site Moderators, FAHC Science Team
Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
If donors received monetary compensation, surely the number of donors would grow. But I'm curious if Folding@Home or others in need of vast computing power would be willing to pay users? Hypothetically, if there were payment, maybe the network would become very vast and the immense computing power available might be useful to certain users? Thoughts?
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Tue Apr 21, 2009 4:41 pm
- Hardware configuration: Mac Studio M1 Max 32 GB smp6
Mac Hack i7-7700K 48 GB smp4 - Location: W. MA
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
If you are looking for an answer from PG, this type of question is best asked on the official reddit page - https://www.reddit.com/r/foldingathome/.
However based on my experience, the answer is no. There just is not that kind of money available in research budgets to pay persons processing WU's for distributed computing projects. Most research grants do not allow that kind of use of the money given to researchers and their schools.
However based on my experience, the answer is no. There just is not that kind of money available in research budgets to pay persons processing WU's for distributed computing projects. Most research grants do not allow that kind of use of the money given to researchers and their schools.
-
- Posts: 10179
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 4:30 pm
- Hardware configuration: Intel i7-4770K @ 4.5 GHz, 16 GB DDR3-2133 Corsair Vengence (black/red), EVGA GTX 760 @ 1200 MHz, on an Asus Maximus VI Hero MB (black/red), in a blacked out Antec P280 Tower, with a Xigmatek Night Hawk (black) HSF, Seasonic 760w Platinum (black case, sleeves, wires), 4 SilenX 120mm Case fans with silicon fan gaskets and silicon mounts (all black), a 512GB Samsung SSD (black), and a 2TB Black Western Digital HD (silver/black).
- Location: Arizona
- Contact:
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
There are several crypto currency projects giving out credits for folding. Not sure what the pay rate is, but there are a good number of people on those teams.
How to provide enough information to get helpful support
Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn.
Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn.
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
Ah OK, I see, thanks; that makes sense.
-
- Posts: 2040
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
- Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
There is a project called curecoin which gives you a little money for folding but it is maybe lower than what you pay for the electricity.
I think the idea of getting paid for folding would work if the government or a company would have some dollars to spend for folding, excluding uses like pay more developers or advertising. Then the decision is to make 1) pay for cloud computing or computer center or 2) pay for folding at home.
If option 2) is cheaper and price is high enough to attract the power users with their GPUs or maybe many people with fast smartphones then this is were folding@home gets really powerful.
The idea is the users already have the hardware they just need to run the folding software and pay the electricity. So for the users to make profit, you need to pay their price for electricity plus the profit to the users. e.g. a PC with 500 Watt will cost 0,25$/kwh * 0,5kw * 24h = 3$ a day electricity producing 5 TFlops on a fast GPU. Plus 1$ profit for the user this is 4 dollars a day for 5 Tflops to pay. The users living in regions with lower electricity price will profit more others less.
In comparison an amazon cloud g2.2xlarge using GRID K520 has 2.5 Tflops and costs 0.65$ per hour. To match my PC example this is 1.30$ per hour for 5 Tflops and 31$ per day. In this case the folding PC wins with price 4$ per day. If we increase the profit for the user from 1$ to 10$ per day and add electricity cost 3$ this is 13$ to pay in total - then PC still wins.
I think the idea of getting paid for folding would work if the government or a company would have some dollars to spend for folding, excluding uses like pay more developers or advertising. Then the decision is to make 1) pay for cloud computing or computer center or 2) pay for folding at home.
If option 2) is cheaper and price is high enough to attract the power users with their GPUs or maybe many people with fast smartphones then this is were folding@home gets really powerful.
The idea is the users already have the hardware they just need to run the folding software and pay the electricity. So for the users to make profit, you need to pay their price for electricity plus the profit to the users. e.g. a PC with 500 Watt will cost 0,25$/kwh * 0,5kw * 24h = 3$ a day electricity producing 5 TFlops on a fast GPU. Plus 1$ profit for the user this is 4 dollars a day for 5 Tflops to pay. The users living in regions with lower electricity price will profit more others less.
In comparison an amazon cloud g2.2xlarge using GRID K520 has 2.5 Tflops and costs 0.65$ per hour. To match my PC example this is 1.30$ per hour for 5 Tflops and 31$ per day. In this case the folding PC wins with price 4$ per day. If we increase the profit for the user from 1$ to 10$ per day and add electricity cost 3$ this is 13$ to pay in total - then PC still wins.
Last edited by foldy on Tue Jul 26, 2016 9:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
Would you show how you get to that pricing from this AWS pricing sheet?: https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/dedicated-hosts/pricing/
They don't seem to spell it out and just trying to compare apples-to-apples.
They don't seem to spell it out and just trying to compare apples-to-apples.
-
- Posts: 2040
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:43 pm
- Hardware configuration: Folding@Home Client 7.6.13 (1 GPU slots)
Windows 7 64bit
Intel Core i5 2500k@4Ghz
Nvidia gtx 1080ti driver 441
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
Region USA East (North-Virginia)
https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/pricing/
GPU-Instances - g2.2xlarge - $0.65 per hour
https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/dedicated-hosts/pricing/
g2 Instance is 4x g2.2xlarge = 10 Tflops
On demand 2.86$ per hour
Prepay for one year $15307
https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/pricing/
GPU-Instances - g2.2xlarge - $0.65 per hour
https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/dedicated-hosts/pricing/
g2 Instance is 4x g2.2xlarge = 10 Tflops
On demand 2.86$ per hour
Prepay for one year $15307
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
Got it, thanks.
-
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Sun Feb 28, 2016 10:06 pm
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
If they filed this as a non-profit they could work out a way to get your donation taken off your taxes I bet.
Dedicated to my grandparents who have passed away from Alzheimer's
Dedicated folding rig on Linux Mint 19.1:
2 - GTX 980 OC +200
1 - GTX 980 Ti OC +20
4 - GTX 1070 FE OC +200
3 - GTX 1080 OC +140
1 - GTX 1080Ti OC +120
-
- Posts: 10179
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 4:30 pm
- Hardware configuration: Intel i7-4770K @ 4.5 GHz, 16 GB DDR3-2133 Corsair Vengence (black/red), EVGA GTX 760 @ 1200 MHz, on an Asus Maximus VI Hero MB (black/red), in a blacked out Antec P280 Tower, with a Xigmatek Night Hawk (black) HSF, Seasonic 760w Platinum (black case, sleeves, wires), 4 SilenX 120mm Case fans with silicon fan gaskets and silicon mounts (all black), a 512GB Samsung SSD (black), and a 2TB Black Western Digital HD (silver/black).
- Location: Arizona
- Contact:
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
They have been a nonprofit all along. There is even a donation link on the Fah web page setup for that.
The problem is, in 15 years of the project, no one has figured out how to value the work units that you donate, so kind of hard for the IRS to accept that.
The problem is, in 15 years of the project, no one has figured out how to value the work units that you donate, so kind of hard for the IRS to accept that.
How to provide enough information to get helpful support
Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn.
Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn.
Re: Would Folding@Home Pay for Computing Power?
The link allows you to donate money or a computer or other property to Stanford. Once you've done that, they own it and their admins decide what run there, not you. If you donate money (or property, or whatever) the tax agents know how to define what that asset was worth.The problem is, in 15 years of the project, no one has figured out how to value the work units that you donate, so kind of hard for the IRS to accept that.
Those agents have trouble, though, when you donate a fraction of your home as a "home office" or a (small?) portion of your computer that has an undefined value. FAH management repeatedly says it's using unused resources on your computer so you can't claim the whole computer ... so they disallow and estimates of fractional value. (Besides, they also say not to buy hardware based on running FAH.) Allocating a few percent of your electric bill is a pretty shaky proposition, too.
A conscientious tax agent is likely to look at a statement like:
and say: Ok, your contribution for last year was worth less than half a dollar, so it rounds off to zero.There is a project called curecoin which gives you a little money for folding but it is maybe lower than what you pay for the electricity.
Posting FAH's log:
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.
How to provide enough info to get helpful support.