Page 1 of 2

Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 2:13 pm
by comixgoddess
The following WU's were successfully uploaded to server 128.252.203.11, but no credit was issued. In all instances, I received the "WORK_ACK" response and a final credit estimate. My work units couldn't be found on the WU Status page, but I did find a previously completed unit by another folder for each one.

2020-12-21 — project:16462 run:128 clone:4 gen:1 - returned by another user on 2020-12-09
2020-12-21 — project:16460 run:0 clone:689 gen:14 - returned by another user on 2020-12-05
2020-12-22 — project:16462 run:114 clone:3 gen:11 - returned by another user on 2020-12-09
2020-12-22 — project:16462 run:135 clone:4 gen:23 - returned by another user on 2020-12-11

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 3:36 pm
by goodyca
I'm seeing the same thing on the subject server.

The following WU's were successfully uploaded to the subject server, but no credit was issued. I have checked the WU Status of each at https://apps.foldingathome.org/wu, and they were all previously returned by another user.

Completion Time and Project Description
12/21/20 01:36 AM Project: 16460 (Run 0, Clone 859, Gen 0) - returned by Wiinikolia 12-3-2020
12/21/20 02:49 AM Project: 16458 (Run 28, Clone 1, Gen 4) - returned by bs0kx3xrbuq4 12-5-2020
12/21/20 04:01 AM Project: 16462 (Run 54, Clone 0, Gen 5) - returned by benederschene 12-7-2020
12/21/20 11:33 AM Project: 16461 (Run 29, Clone 1, Gen 6) - returned by Anonymous 12-8-2020
12/21/20 12:10 PM Project: 16461 (Run 50, Clone 0, Gen 12) - returned by Intel_Diamond 12-9-2020
12/21/20 04:02 PM Project: 16461 (Run 35, Clone 4, Gen 14) - returned by jpc303 12-8-2020
12/22/20 06:39 AM Project: 16460 (Run 0, Clone 1442, Gen 9) - returned by Rambo 12-4-2020 and AnotherAlex 12-4-2020
12/22/20 08:24 AM Project: 16461 (Run 44, Clone 1, Gen 24) - returned by Anonymous 12-11-2020
12/22/20 10:15 AM Project: 16460 (Run 0, Clone 372, Gen 22) - returned by konana1977 12-5-2020

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 6:20 pm
by Joe_H
I will pass this on, they have been having intermittent problems like this as they update and set up projects on the new servers.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 5:02 am
by comixgoddess
Thank you, Joe_H :D The credits for my work units just showed up on the WU Status page.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 5:13 am
by psaam0001
Let us keep our fingers crossed, that any new grants which are allocated to fund F@H (or the Universities behind the projects we are helping with) in 2021, will allow for hiring additional IT support staff (to keep up with doing the maintenance/upgrades).

Paul

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2020 8:11 am
by PantherX
psaam0001 wrote:...any new grants which are allocated to fund F@H (or the Universities behind the projects we are helping with) in 2021, will allow for hiring additional IT support staff...
Generally speaking, when grants are allocated by Government or other means, they can be very restricted in what F@H can do with them. It has been that way when dealing with public grants. Hence, public donations (https://anand-bhat.github.io/foldingath ... contribute) are really valuable since they can be used for any reason by F@H :)

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2020 2:24 pm
by psaam0001
I'm making a note to offer a few $$$ once the post holiday bills are paid.... Starting w/my local electric co-op so the lights & heat stay on, the water is warm, and the folding continues.

If I had more experience as an IT professional, I'd volunteer my time to help w/the regular server maintenance. If only to be compensated with a 1/2 liter cup of fresh coffee in the morning.

Paul

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 12:21 am
by PantherX
psaam0001 wrote:...If I had more experience as an IT professional, I'd volunteer my time to help w/the regular server maintenance. If only to be compensated with a 1/2 liter cup of fresh coffee in the morning...
FYI, if you're keen to volunteer for F@H, have a look at the Discord Dev since that's where you can volunteer too. Of course, volunteering on the Forum is also fantastic too :)

FYI, when it comes to Server Maintenance, it would be very tricky to provide access to volunteers since those Servers live in different organizations meaning that there's various paperwork involved depending on where you live and what not. The HR/Legal overhead might be enough to not pursue this.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 1:30 am
by psaam0001
I've been trying to help on the forum as much as I can (with the limited knowledge of the various distributions of Linux; and 0% knowledge of cloud computing)...

Yeah, the travel time from VA to where the servers are, and the legal/HR overhead would be a bit much. I'll just build a few more folding systems as my money supply allows. Besides, I'm not wanting to physically enter a foreign country right now.

Paul

PS: I bookmarked the donation info link.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 5:29 pm
by bruce
As was previously stated, government grants for research are frequently restricted to RESEARCH, so the tasks associated with support staff generally falls to grad students or other "volunteers." Then, too, each University has it's own network administration staff with their own policies (and they don't work for FAH).

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2020 6:27 pm
by psaam0001
Understood.

Paul

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Mon Dec 28, 2020 1:05 pm
by gunnarre
Missing credit for project:16460 run:0 clone:1918 gen:42, but this one was at least not already done by someone else months ago.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Mon Dec 28, 2020 3:39 pm
by _r2w_ben
Missing credit for project:16462 run:10 clone:4 gen:29 completed Dec 26.

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2021 12:27 pm
by ComputerUser
Hi,

i also finished several WUs from this server without getting credits, first noted on project:16459 run:40 clone:3 gen:68 (completed on 2020-01-04 16:02:43). Going backwards on the 'gen' number using the WU app i noticed that the last WU from my run which has been credited was gen 55, credited on 2021-01-01 00:50:37 - every WU after this date is missing, so probably the server connection to the stats server broke at this time.

Cheers,
Computeruser

Re: Missing credit server 128.252.203.11

Posted: Thu Jan 07, 2021 2:05 pm
by Neil-B
hopefully the stats setup for this server will get a kick soon ... in the mean time as long as you are getting the successful upload confirmation messages and estimated points statements in the logs you can start looking forward to the bumper points spike when the service catches up (as it invariable does eventually). :)